Contact the study team if you received this page in error.
đŹ Surgical Video Peer Review
SCALE Study â Peer Review Platform
đ¤ Step 1: Audio Quality Test
Before starting, we need to verify your microphone quality.
đ Important Instructions:
Close all videos, music, and other media players before starting
Speak clearly into your microphone
Say: "I am testing audio for surgical annotation tool"
Ensure you are in a quiet environment
Ready to test. Click "Start Test" below.
00:00
Volume Level
-
Duration
-
Dynamic Range
-
đ Step 2: Review Instructions
đŹ Open Review
Review the entire surgical procedure and comment on surgical quality, defined as intraoperative behaviors that impact patient outcomes. If you were giving feedback while this surgeon was operating, what would you tell them? Examples include general categories of technical execution, decision-making/judgement, safety/critical moments, or specific things to work on.
â ď¸ You must watch the ENTIRE video. You may adjust playback speed or skip less relevant sections, but please ensure you review the full procedure before completing your evaluation.
đąď¸ Mouse Tracking â Important:
While watching the video, keep your mouse cursor over the area of the video you are currently focusing on.
Move your cursor to follow your area of attention â for example, point at the instrument tip, tissue, or anatomical structure you are commenting on.
Your cursor position on the video will be recorded alongside your audio commentary to help us understand your focus of attention.
You do not need to click â simply hover your mouse over the relevant area.
đ Evaluation Tasks
Welcome! Select a task to begin.
FULL VIDEO
GOALS / GEARS Assessment
Standardized Skill Assessment
Watch full procedure videos and score surgical skill using GOALS (laparoscopic) or GEARS (robotic) criteria while providing verbal commentary on each dimension.
đ 5 Videosâąď¸ ~15 min each
FULL VIDEO
Open Review
Open Peer Commentary
Watch full procedure videos and provide open-ended verbal commentary on surgical quality â technical execution, decision-making, safety moments, and specific things to work on.
đŹ 5 Videosâąď¸ ~15 min each
Videos
0 of 5 videos evaluated
Video Evaluation
Video 1
đ Video Evaluation
â ď¸ You must watch the ENTIRE video. You may adjust playback speed or skip less relevant sections, but please ensure you review the full procedure before completing your evaluation.
đąď¸ Mouse Tracking â Important:
While watching the video, keep your mouse cursor over the area of the video you are currently focusing on.
Move your cursor to follow your area of attention â for example, point at the instrument tip, tissue, or anatomical structure you are commenting on.
Your cursor position on the video will be recorded alongside your audio commentary to help us understand your focus of attention.
You do not need to click â simply hover your mouse over the relevant area.
GOALS: Global Assessment of Laparoscopic Skills
Dimension
1 (Poor)
3 (Average)
5 (Excellent)
1. Depth Perception
Constantly overshoots
Some overshooting
Accurately directs
2. Bimanual Dexterity
One hand, poor coordination
Both hands, not optimal
Expert complementary use
3. Efficiency
Uncertain, tentative
Slow but planned
Confident, efficient
4. Tissue Handling
Rough, tears tissue
Reasonable, minor trauma
Gentle, negligible injury
5. Autonomy
Unable even with guidance
Needs moderate guidance
Completes independently
GEARS: Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills
Dimension
1 (Poor)
3 (Average)
5 (Excellent)
1. Depth Perception
Constantly exceeds target
Some failures but corrected
Directs in correct plane
2. Bimanual Skill
One hand, poor coordination
Both hands, not optimal
Complementary for exposure
3. Efficiency
Tentative, no progress
Slow but organized
Confident, efficient
4. Force Control
Jerking, tears tissue
Reasonable handling
Proper handling, no breaking
5. Autonomy
Unable to complete
Some guidance needed
Completes alone
6. Robot Control
Poor position, collision
Occasional collision
Optimal, no collision
Tracking cursor
0:00 / 0:00
5.0x
00:00
GOALS: Global Assessment of Laparoscopic Skills
â Recording Complete
Duration: 0:00
GEARS: Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills
â Recording Complete
Duration: 0:00
â Review Complete
Recording Saved
Duration: 0:00
đ
Thank You!
Your evaluation has been completed successfully
Thank you for participating in this surgical video peer review study.
0
Videos Reviewed
â All data has been submitted successfully
â Data saved
đ¤
Uploading Recording...
Please do not close this page. Your audio recording is being uploaded.
Preparing...
Are you sure you want to end the recording? Make sure you have reviewed the entire video.